You are here: Home » Recipes » Creamy Potato Soup Creamy Potato Soup Recipe by TeamErnie Yield 3 to 5 servings PrintEmail Ingredients 4 potatoes2 onions3 stalks of celery1/2 teaspoon salt2 tablespoons butter1 cup milk1 cup chicken broth1/2 teaspoon paprika1/4 teaspoon pepper Instructions Peel and dice potatoes. Add potatoes, onions, and celery into heavy pot with enough boiling water to cover potatoes, onions and celery. Add salt, cover and cook until potatoes are tender. Drain and press through a sieve. Add butter and heat. Add enough milk and broth to reach desired consistency. Add pepper, paprika and additional salt if needed. Simmer 10 to 15 minutes.