You are here: Home » Recipes » Delightful Peeps S’Mores Delightful Peeps S’Mores Recipe by Relish Yield S’mores with Peep marshmallows are treats that are as fun as they are sweet. PrintEmail With all the different flavors and colors of Peep marshmallows now available, you can really get creative with this recipe! We think the gingerbread or peppermint flavored marshmallows would make some pretty tasty s’mores, too. Ingredients Regular or chocolate graham crackers, broken into squares Assorted Peeps Semisweet or bittersweet chocolate, broken into squares Instructions Place half the graham crackers on a baking sheet. Top each with two Peep marshmallows. Run under broiler until Peeps are just toasted and browned. Top each marshmallow with chocolate and another graham cracker. Enjoy! NOTE: Amount of each ingredient depends on how many s’mores you plan on making.